Il Paiolo

Reviews

• Nick N.

  star star star star star 3 June 2026

  Holy cannoli is all I can say. Jeremy is the BEST. Ask for him the next time that you come here . He hooked it up and got us all we wanted and more. Get the steak because it was incredible. You can definitely share with three people because it's humungo

• Winnie Z.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 27 May 2026

  we ordered T-bone steak and ravioli.
  The waiter even didn't ask us that how we like our steak.
  And it came with half overcooked and half medium rare.
  For the ravioli,can you believe that it's raw??
  Though the waiters were gentle,the food is NOT worth your time and money!!

• Luis M.

  star star star star star 24 May 2026

  First time in Florence, amazing food and service. Pino our server was friendly and informative and patiently explained the menu to us as well as some recommendations. Will definitely be returning in the future !

• Alexandra T.

  star star star star star_border 21 May 2026

  First time at Il Paiolo a month ago for dinner with a group of 7 at 8:30pm when vacationing in Florence! We needed a last minute reservation on a Friday evening and Il Paiolo came to the rescue. It was a recommendation to try it out from a close friend and it didn't disappoint!
  
  We started out with the artichoke and burrata plate to split. We then got gnocchi sorrentina, which was so fresh and simple! We also got the tripe and it was one of the best we had in all of Florence. It's easy to make tripe gummy but the texture was perfect and the sauce was extremely flavorful.
  
  Would definitely recommend giving this restaurant a shot! They have a very expansive wine list. Service was average; we initially felt a little rushed but the waiter took the hint to not speed up our meal.

• Bryce S.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 16 May 2026

  The food was very good but service was horrendous. Our waiter I think was moved to the front of the restaurant and we were left waiting for over an hour in between our first and second courses. The couple next to us, seated over half and hour after my family received their first second and third course in the time we got our first. The waiters seemed to have a complete disregard for me and my family and our waiter refused to even look the way of our table. Truly a sad experience as the restaurants menu looked very good but the service was unfortunately terrible.